"I do not speak because I have the strength to speak; I speak because I do not have the strength to remain silent. "

Jalal Boubker Bennani

Author Living Together

Jalal B. Benanni

MEDIA LIBRARY

Each message is, at least implicitly, a response to a message from someone else who was, in turn, a response to an intervention from another, etc. Our almost infinite capacity for dialogue can awaken and promote exchanges and debates in order to establish a true climate of coexistence, fraternity and good living among all Moroccan citizens.

Toumliline Gallery - Photo Details

Amédée Lefebvre received by King Mohammed V on August 23, 1957. (Coll. Belin, CADN) See on the back of the photo the instructions of Bishop Amédée Lefebvre to the Benedictine monks

Bishop Amédée Lefebvre's instructions to the Benedictine monks, freshly installed in their monastery: "Only contemplatives can break down the age-old barriers between Christians and Muslims. You will show a face of the Church that is appreciated by the Koran. I am not asking you to baptize, but to exercise Benedictine hospitality, to make friends with Moroccans, to begin a dialogue in mutual esteem and respect.

Speech by King Mohammed V

Extracts from the speech of King Mohammed V to the assignees of Toumliline (August 29, 1956)

[Our country is all the more pleased and proud of this because the object of your preoccupation had nothing in common with the materialism so pervasive today. On the contrary, you have sought the paths that lead to spiritual values and that allow humanity to climb the ladder of progress towards a better world.

 

That is why We have followed your work with interest and attention. We found that your ideas corresponded to Our most constant and deepest concerns. We have always advocated a rapprochement between religions and races through an exchange of views and collaboration in a research based on reason. We are convinced that this is the best way to allow the interpenetration of peoples and the enrichment of cultures. We believe that it is through such efforts that mankind has advanced in the life of civilization and has reached today a high stage in all fields.

The presence of eminent men from Europe, Africa and Asia, the participation of representatives of religious denominations, of men interested in the social progress of humanity, of personalities belonging to the world of science and politics, such as the famous orientalist M. Louis Massignon, could only enhance the brilliance of your meetings and arouse a more lively interest, in Morocco and abroad. On the other hand, the assignees have studied problems in various fields, the importance of which deserves to be underlined…

 

[…] As a link between the Eastern and Western worlds, a melting pot for various cultures, Morocco must be among the nations interested in the things of the mind and working for the progress of human knowledge…

 

 [You know that morality, spiritual values, virtue and civic-mindedness are the foundations of the city in Islam. These are the very principles that We are attached to, that We advocate and that We have never ceased to defend. We are convinced that this is the only way to progress and civilization.

 

The new Morocco has no intention of isolating itself and closing in on itself. We are determined to turn this country into an open community, maintaining relations with all countries on the basis of cooperation and exchange. As an Arab and Muslim country, Morocco is a land of welcome and hospitality…

(Confluent, n°7, December 1956, p.6-7)

Denis' speech to King Mohammed at the Royal Palace in Rabat on August 29, 1958:

[…] If this international meeting has taken on such importance and splendor, it is obviously thanks to the high patronage that Your Majesty has kindly granted us, at the suggestion of His Highness Prince Moulay Hassan...
[…] Here are the assignees. They have come from more and more countries to meet the Moroccan youth. They were dazzled by the welcome they received from the moment they disembarked in the name of Your Majesty. This welcome, which continued throughout their stay, is now crowned by this audience. This success is only a promise for the future. We know, indeed, and this reception is a sign of it, that the high benevolence of Your Majesty will allow this work to play its role according to the true destinies of this country as Your Majesty and His Government have defined them...

(Confluent, n°7, December 1956, p. 5"6)

INAUGURAL SPEECH OF PRINCE MOULAY HASSAN*.

[…] There is no Moroccan who is not universalist. Sometimes, it appears narrow. It is quite normal. He has not yet completely rid himself of his complex. But give him two or three more years, let him free his personality, but then he will give himself to you, to the world, with a lot of liberation, because he will have fewer complexes. He has been independent for a year, barely two years, and every manifestation from abroad he sees as perhaps a reminder of a period he fought against, of a regime he did not want.

 

Friendly lunch. In the center of the photo, Prince Moulay Hassan and Archbishop Amédée Lefèvre. See on the back of the picture the inaugural speech of Prince Moulay Hassan.

[In this country that His Majesty the King hopes to see become the link between the East and the West, well in this country, ladies and gentlemen, you are at home. For the good man, the believer, the honest man is at home everywhere. In fact, when we go back to the sources of religions, whether it is the Hebrew religion, the Christian religion or the Muslim religion, we are not told: “Do not pray in the wilderness. On the contrary, the world is the house of God. Every believer can make his prayer there. Every believer can meet his god there. Every believer can find his ideal there. So this country of yours is above all the house of God, it is the house of all Believers, the house of all men who have equal aspirations for a better world.

 

 * Session 1957, theme Education. Brilliant conference in front of 150 delegates from 26 countries.

 

Prince Moulay El Hassan, speaking to the children of Azrou, recommended that they follow the advice of the monks as well as their own fathers:

 

“You know that your fathers never advise you anything bad, because they love you. In the same way, the Fathers love you; you can be sure that they will never teach you anything but good.

 

This was reported by Father Denis during his inaugural speech at the Toumliline summer school in August 1956.

Participation of Princess Lalla Aicha, symbol of the emancipation of Moroccan women, in the 1957 session of Toumliline. -Coll. En-Calcat-. See on the back of the picture the speech of the princess.

INTERVENTION OF PRINCESS LALLA AÏCHA

Princess Lalla Aïcha made a very remarkable presentation on the emancipation of Moroccan women* and mainly on the wearing of the veil where she courageously expressed her opinion which was also, she underlined, that of her father, King Mohammed V:  

 

“Harmoniously, without clashes, the woman must be brought to be an integral part of the life of the country.

 

Emancipation must be accepted as a liberation of the personality, an enrichment, a blossoming of the individual, and not as an anarchic attitude, artificially attacking certain external elements, such as the veil for example.

 

The veil has always been considered as the symbol of the inferior condition of the woman. To remove it, it has been thought, is at the same time to give back to the woman her freedom, to remove her gag which prevents her from breathing and from expressing herself.

This is a somewhat artificial view of the problem. The only thing that counts is the woman’s awareness of her rights and duties. The rest is self-evident. Free to determine herself, free to choose, the woman will be able to remove the veil or keep it, but then she will keep it as an ornament and not as a gag or a straitjacket.

 

(Toumliline 2: Aspects de l’éducation, Publication du monastère de Toumliline, Rabat, Ecole du Livre, 1958,p.153.)

 

 * Session 1957, theme: Education

Ahmed Balafrej, Minister of Foreign Affairs, talking with Louis Massignon, (Coll. En-Calcat). See the back of the photo.

Louis Massignon, a great mystic and great Arabist, knowing as well the Sunni and Shiite theology as the Muslim mysticism, a very committed Christian and a great fervent of the Islamic-Christian dialogue. He spoke at Toumliline in 1956 on spiritual values: "The Presence of God in the Ideal Cities of Muslim Thinkers" from autobiographical, theological, historical, philosophical and anthropological angles. He also intervened in 1957 to deal with "The Education of Man".

THE MONK AND THE SHEIKH

When he (Fr. Denis) had begun to associate with the Great Sheikh of Islam in Morocco, Fqih Bel Larbi El Alaoui, both Colonel Clesca and General Miquel had warned him that he was the worst enemy of the Church in Morocco. He had been told of an incident that took place during a lecture by Bel Larbi to students at the University of Karaouiyine in Fez. The sound of the bells of a Catholic church had penetrated the courtyard where they were. This is our real enemy,” the Fqih told the students, “do not rest until you have driven him out of our country.

The Monk and the Sheikh

But when Fr. Prieur had become quite intimate with the Muslim theologian, he asked him if the story was true. The Fqih admitted it perfectly, but added that at that time he did not distinguish between the Church and the French authorities. Whereas now,” he said, “what I see you doing in Toumliline has helped me to make the distinction.

 

Later, after many conversations in which each came to understand the aspirations of the other’s religion, Bel Larbi admitted something surprising. “I would respect the conversion of a Muslim to Christianity as I would desire yours to Islam. But of course, such a desire must always respect the personality and freedom of conscience of others. Conversion cannot be achieved by violence or argument, but by the radiance of a life lived in accord with this truth.

 

Peter Beach and William Dunphy, Benedictine and Moor: A Christian adventure in moslem Morocco, 1960, p.55.

Nika Paul-Pont greeting the Sovereign. See the back of the photo for a note from the representative of India

Ms. Nika Paul Pont, delegate of the government of New Delhi to the International Children's Centre in Paris, made a remarkable presentation on "Social Education in India", an education based on the spiritual values of Hinduism and based on the freedom of individual conscience. A lively debate followed, mainly with Mehdi Ben Barka

Mehdi Ben Barka, Abdallah Ibrahim and Nika Paul-Pont. See the back of the photo for an overview of Mehdi Ben Barka's talk (on the right of the photo) dedicated to the Moroccan university

Mehdi Ben Barka, then president of the National Consultative Assembly, made a presentation dedicated to the Moroccan university in which he emphasized that "everything we do, everything we build, everything we undertake will remain precarious, if it is not built on science, on a solid education. A country that does not have researchers, that does not have scholars, is doomed to slavery, and deserves only slavery. That is why, during our first year of independence, we concentrated our efforts on educational problems.

Mahjoubi Aherdan & P. Denis

Mahjoub Aherdane, in an interview with the Archives of Morocco and the Memory for the Future Foundation.

 

“What is a pity is that this monastery was not allowed to live. Our religion was not threatened (…). They are people of God, people who do their utmost to help, and they are open people.

 

In his memoirs, Mahjoub Aherdane evokes this unique pilot experience: “I have kept a nice memory of the Benedictines present in Toumliline, not far from Azrou. The rapprochement of religions, obviously without a future, had its time of glory and piety shared between the tonsured, hands joined in a murmured prayer, and the Muslims in ties who discovered Jesus at the same time as the cedars of the Middle Atlas and the existence of monkeys in the forests of the country. (…) For a time, Christians and Muslims had become brothers…

Mahjoubi Aherdan, Governor of Rabat, with Fr. Denis, (CADN, Fonds Belin). See testimony on the back of the photo

Testimony of Fatéma Hassar

Father Denis with Mrs. Fatéma Hassar. In the background, in the middle, Mrs. Schluter Hernkes, delegate of Federal Germany to the Unesco Board of Directors who spoke at the August 1956 session on "The Role of Women in International Life". (Coll. En-Calcat) Fatéma Hassar, icon of the militancy in favor of the evolution of the Moroccan woman, in an interview granted to Confluent (Toumliline 1956): "We will keep the best memory of the cultural sessions that you just organized in Toumliline. Because it is the first international meeting of this kind which was held in an independent and unified Morocco. Our country is all the more happy and proud of it because the object of your preoccupations had nothing in common with this materialism so invasive nowadays."
Testimonials

"For we did not meet them as people who pass each other in the streets, but as men of the same family, or as pilgrims who travel together towards a common homeland, as men who share the same house, the same roof, the same meal. We have understood, more intimately than in the past, that we are co-owners of riches that are much more lasting, less transient than the things of this world, that is, of spiritual, profound and primordial values."

"To hear a Muslim prince talk about education in a Benedictine monastery is not commonplace! There must be a great friendship between these monks and Morocco for the royal family and members of the Moroccan government to participate in this session and to accept to answer all the questions - there will be some and many perilous ones!

"For we did not meet them as people who pass each other in the streets, but as men of the same family, or as pilgrims who travel together towards a common homeland, as men who share the same house, the same roof, the same meal. We have understood, more intimately than in the past, that we are co-owners of riches that are much more lasting, less transient than the things of this world, that is, of spiritual, profound and primordial values."